Supreme Court Rules on Vaccine Mandates

Healthcare providers are now required to ensure that workers either are vaccinated or obtained an exemption.

Last month, I noted that the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) had filed appeal notices in both the 8th and 5th circuits to quash injunctions imposed by those courts.

Unsurprisingly, the cases ended up in the Supreme Court. The Court, consisting of nine fully vaccinated justices, heard oral arguments on Jan. 7 regarding both the Department of Labor and the HHS injunctions.

On Jan. 13, the Court issued decisions in both cases. The recordings, transcripts, and decisions are available on the Supreme Court’s website, but I’ll cover the highlights. In the case of the Department of Labor, the Court ruled 6-3 against the government. This means that businesses with greater than 100 employees are not subject to a vaccinate-or-test requirement (for now).

More important, for this audience, is the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) case. The Court found in a 5-4 decision that the imposition of a vaccine mandate for healthcare providers is within the scope of the HHS Secretary’s authority – here’s the key part – as a condition of participation in federal health programs. As the Court stated, “we agree with the Government that the Secretary’s rule falls within the authorities that Congress has conferred upon him.” The Court continued, stating that “Congress has authorized the Secretary to impose conditions on the receipt of Medicaid and Medicare funds that the Secretary finds necessary in the interest of the health and safety of individuals who are (receiving) furnished services.” This holding is crucial, because it may be an insurmountable obstacle for future challenges to vaccination requirements.

The Court’s decision answered, at least temporarily, the question of the ability of the Secretary to impose this mandate – everywhere except Texas. That’s because Texas had separately filed suit. But on Jan. 19, a federal judge in Texas dismissed that case as well. Within one day of the decision, CMS issued guidance.

So, where exactly does that leave us? As of today, Jan. 24, the vaccine mandate is in effect for all hospitals in every state, with varying dates of compliance. The decision does not change the original compliance dates. For the states covered by the Court’s Jan. 13 decision, the relevant dates are Feb. 14 and March 15, according to a Joint Commission statement. For Texas, the dates are likely Feb. 19 and March 20.

The Joint Commission has already announced that on Jan. 27, it will begin assessing compliance as a component of its survey process. One-hundred percent compliance with the regulation is required. Thus, employees must be vaccinated or be covered by a recognized exemption. There are only two good-faith efforts considered in determining the level of deficiency:

  • Limited access to vaccine; or
  • Evidence of aggressive steps to have all staff vaccinated.

The Joint Commission will also expect very specific documentation related to vaccination, including:

  • A list of all staff and vaccination status;
  • Vaccination rates, excluding exempted staff, and methods of tracking vaccination and exemptions; and
  • Policies regarding vaccination.

This not going to get any less complicated, and the stakes are very high for hospitals.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

John K. Hall, MD, JD, MBA, FCLM, FRCPC

John K. Hall, MD, JD, MBA, FCLM, FRCPC is a licensed physician in several jurisdictions and is admitted to the California bar. He is also the founder of The Aegis Firm, a healthcare consulting firm providing consultative and litigation support on a wide variety of criminal and civil matters related to healthcare. He lectures frequently on black-letter health law, mediation, medical staff relations, and medical ethics, as well as patient and physician rights. Dr. Hall hopes to help explain complex problems at the intersection of medicine and law and prepare providers to manage those problems.

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Mastering Principal Diagnosis: Coding Precision, Medical Necessity, and Quality Impact

Mastering Principal Diagnosis: Coding Precision, Medical Necessity, and Quality Impact

Accurately determining the principal diagnosis is critical for compliant billing, appropriate reimbursement, and valid quality reporting — yet it remains one of the most subjective and error-prone areas in inpatient coding. In this expert-led session, Cheryl Ericson, RN, MS, CCDS, CDIP, demystifies the complexities of principal diagnosis assignment, bridging the gap between coding rules and clinical reality. Learn how to strengthen your organization’s coding accuracy, reduce denials, and ensure your documentation supports true medical necessity.

December 3, 2025

Proactive Denial Management: Data-Driven Strategies to Prevent Revenue Loss

Denials continue to delay reimbursement, increase administrative burden, and threaten financial stability across healthcare organizations. This essential webcast tackles the root causes—rising payer scrutiny, fragmented workflows, inconsistent documentation, and underused analytics—and offers proven, data-driven strategies to prevent and overturn denials. Attendees will gain practical tools to strengthen documentation and coding accuracy, engage clinicians effectively, and leverage predictive analytics and AI to identify risks before they impact revenue. Through real-world case examples and actionable guidance, this session empowers coding, CDI, and revenue cycle professionals to shift from reactive appeals to proactive denial prevention and revenue protection.

November 19, 2025
Sepsis: Bridging the Clinical Documentation and Coding Gap to Reduce Denials

Sepsis: Bridging the Clinical Documentation and Coding Gap to Reduce Denials

Sepsis remains one of the most frequently denied and contested diagnoses, creating costly revenue loss and compliance risks. In this webcast, Angela Comfort, DBA, MBA, RHIA, CDIP, CCS, CCS-P, provides practical, real-world strategies to align documentation with coding guidelines, reconcile Sepsis-2 and Sepsis-3 definitions, and apply compliant queries. You’ll learn how to identify and address documentation gaps, strengthen provider engagement, and defend diagnoses against payer scrutiny—equipping you to protect reimbursement, improve SOI/ROM capture, and reduce audit vulnerability in this high-risk area.

September 24, 2025

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Surviving Federal Audits for Inpatient Rehab Facility Services

Surviving Federal Audits for Inpatient Rehab Facility Services

Federal auditors are zeroing in on Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility (IRF) and hospital rehab unit services, with OIG and CERT audits leading to millions in penalties—often due to documentation and administrative errors, not quality of care. Join compliance expert Michael Calahan, PA, MBA, to learn the five clinical “pillars” of IRF-PPS admissions, key documentation requirements, and real-life case lessons to help protect your revenue.

November 13, 2025
E/M Services Under Intensive Federal Scrutiny: Navigating Split/Shared, Incident-to & Critical Care Compliance in 2025-2026

E/M Services Under Intensive Federal Scrutiny: Navigating Split/Shared, Incident-to & Critical Care Compliance in 2025-2026

During this essential RACmonitor webcast Michael Calahan, PA, MBA Certified Compliance Officer, will clarify the rules, dispel common misconceptions, and equip you with practical strategies to code, document, and bill high-risk split/shared, incident-to & critical care E/M services with confidence. Don’t let audit risks or revenue losses catch your organization off guard — learn exactly what federal auditors are looking for and how to ensure your documentation and reporting stand up to scrutiny.

August 26, 2025

Trending News

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24