Lessons Learned from Arrested Utah Nurse

The Washington Post (and later, many other media outlets) recently called our attention to an incident in Utah wherein a courageous nurse stood up to a detective who was about to violate a patient’s rights.

The detective with the Salt Lake City Police Department insisted that the hospital draw a blood sample on a patient who was injured when a suspect being chased by police struck his truck. The nurse correctly explained that absent the patient’s consent, a warrant, or the patient being under arrest, it would be improper for the hospital to comply with the officer’s demand.

Tellingly, during the exchange, one of the officers asked, “so why don’t we just write a search warrant?” The detective replied that they “don’t have PC,” meaning that they lack the probable cause necessary to obtain a warrant. In other words, the officers knew that they didn’t have authority to get the blood they were seeking. It appears that they expected to bully their way into getting what they wanted.

The University of Utah Hospital staff, including the nurse, Alex Wubbels, appear to have acted admirably, as well as calmly. The nurse was polite and patient, repeatedly explaining to the officers that they needed to produce a warrant or patient consent. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled last year that the Fourth Amendment prohibits police from taking blood without a warrant. The officers ultimately threatened to arrest the nurse, and then proceeded to do just that, handcuffing her and taking her to a squad car.

One line in the video is easy to miss. The officer says, “I’ve never gone this far.” While we can’t know exactly what the officer means, I strongly suspect that he wasn’t used to someone standing up for the rights of a patient.

Ms. Wubbels deserves tremendous credit. What she did took courage. There was tremendous pressure on her to relent to the officers’ demands. If you watch the entire video, you will see that the officers kept the pressure up for a long time after they cuffed her. The officers eventually calmed down, but persisted, arguing that if they were acting improperly, the justice system would sort the problems out later.

That sort of “act first, ask questions later” approach may sound convincing, but the harm to the patient would already have been done. Later in the video the officer states that “your policy right now is contravening what I need,” also noting that “your policy is interfering with my law.” Those two statements are very different. The first one isn’t relevant. Officers aren’t entitled to get whatever they need, only what the law allows. The second statement, if true, would be more significant. Hospital policy can’t take precedence over the law. However, here, the policy was drafted with the law in mind, and it was the officer, not the hospital, who was disregarding it.

There are several lessons we can learn from the episode. First, it is important to train staff and provide clear policies about interactions with police before a problem arises. The hospital’s conduct in this case was flawless. They were prepared for the situation and responded exactly as I would recommend. The problem here was caused by the officers.

It is unreasonable to expect the care team to know the law as well as this team did. The staff should know, however, to review policy and then, when necessary, to call for advice. That is exactly what happened here. Blindly adhering to policy can be problematic. Undoubtedly, some hospitals have policies that are inconsistent with the law. Moreover, even the best policy won’t consider every possible factual scenario. The nurse here escalated the request, involving hospital management in the situation. Note that this situation wasn’t life or death, and there was time to sort things out. In a case like that, a call to the hospital’s office of general counsel is also wise.

Second, again, the nurse remained remarkably calm. When interacting with representatives of the government, keeping your emotions in check and focusing on rational argument is essential. The nurse’s colleagues also stayed calm. In most situations, that would have allowed a rational resolution. Unfortunately, here the officers didn’t appear to act reasonably.

The third lesson relates to documentation. Fortunately, this entire episode was captured on an officer’s body camera. But there is something that the nurse’s colleagues could have done to help ensure that the situation was documented accurately: film it. Unfortunately, there have been a number of instances whereby officers have insisted that filming police “interferes” with them. That is ostensibly untrue. Just as silently watching an action doesn’t prevent it, recording it is not interference. Citizens can record the police. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has an app called Mobile Justice that allows users in 17 states and the District of Columbia to record interactions with the police. When you finish the recording, the app automatically uploads the video so that if the police mistakenly assert that you aren’t allowed to film, and seize the phone, the video is preserved. The app is available in iTunes and Android.

It takes courage to tell someone with a badge and a gun that they are wrong. To preserve our rights in a democracy, however, that courage is necessary. Alex Wubbels did us all a favor in demonstrating exactly how to respond to overly aggressive officers.

If you would like a laminated card explaining your rights and responsibilities as you interact with government agents, please email me at dglaser@fredlaw.com.

Excerpts of the video can be seen online here. The entire 19-minute body camera clip can be seen here.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

David M. Glaser, Esq.

David M. Glaser is a shareholder in Fredrikson & Byron's Health Law Group. David assists clinics, hospitals, and other health care entities negotiate the maze of healthcare regulations, providing advice about risk management, reimbursement, and business planning issues. He has considerable experience in healthcare regulation and litigation, including compliance, criminal and civil fraud investigations, and reimbursement disputes. David's goal is to explain the government's enforcement position, and to analyze whether this position is supported by the law or represents government overreaching. David is a member of the RACmonitor editorial board and is a popular guest on Monitor Mondays.

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Heart Failure Coding Essentials: Ensuring Compliance and Optimal Reimbursement

Heart Failure Coding Essentials: Ensuring Compliance and Optimal Reimbursement

Master the complexities of heart failure coding with this expert-led webcast by Emily Montemayor, CCS, CMBCS, COC, CPC, CPMA. Discover strategies to ensure compliance with ICD-10-CM guidelines, documentation integrity, and capture comorbidities like CKD and hypertension. Learn how to resolve coding challenges, improve documentation practices, and submit clean claims to minimize denials and safeguard your organization’s financial health. With practical insights and real-world examples, this session equips you to prevent revenue leakage, enhance compliance, and secure optimal reimbursement—all while supporting better patient outcomes.

February 26, 2025
Decoding 2025 OPPS Charge Capture and Coding Complexities: Strategies for Success

Decoding 2025 OPPS Charge Capture and Coding Complexities: Strategies for Success

Prepare your organization for the 2025 OPPS updates with expert insights from Tiffani Bouchard, CCS, CRCR, a Revenue Integrity Professional with over 30 years of experience. This webcast will address critical challenges in charge capture and coding, providing clarity on APC policies, C-APC packaging, exclusions, and payer-specific requirements. Attendees will learn actionable strategies to ensure compliance, optimize reimbursement, and mitigate risks of claim denials. Gain the knowledge needed to implement updates effectively, educate your team, and maintain seamless revenue cycle operations in the face of evolving OPPS complexities.

January 29, 2025
Enhancing Outcomes with CDI-Coding-Quality Collaboration in Acute Care Hospitals

Enhancing Outcomes with CDI-Coding-Quality Collaboration in Acute Care Hospitals

Join Angela Comfort, DBA, MBA, RHIA, CDIP, CCS, CCS-P, as she presents effective strategies to strengthen collaboration between CDI, coding, and quality departments in acute care hospitals. Angela will also share guidance on implementing cross-departmental meetings, using shared KPIs, and engaging leadership to foster a culture of collaboration. Attendees will gain actionable tools to optimize documentation accuracy, elevate quality metrics, and drive a unified approach to healthcare goals, ultimately enhancing both patient outcomes and organizational performance.

November 21, 2024

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Navigating the 2025 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule: Key Changes and Strategies for Success

Navigating the 2025 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule: Key Changes and Strategies for Success

The 2025 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule brings significant changes to payment rates, coverage, and coding for physician services, impacting practices nationwide. Join Stanley Nachimson, MS., as he provides a comprehensive guide to understanding these updates, offering actionable insights on new Medicare-covered services, revised coding rules, and payment policies effective January 1. Learn how to adapt your practices to maintain compliance, maximize reimbursement, and plan for revenue in 2025. Whether you’re a physician, coder, or financial staff member, this session equips you with the tools to navigate Medicare’s evolving requirements confidently and efficiently.

January 21, 2025
Patient Notifications and Rights: What You Need to Know

Patient Notifications and Rights: What You Need to Know

Dr. Ronald Hirsch provides critical details on the new Medicare Appeal Process for Status Changes for patients whose status changes during their hospital stay. He also delves into other scenarios of hospital patients receiving custodial care or medically unnecessary services where patient notifications may be needed along with the processes necessary to ensure compliance with state and federal guidance.

December 5, 2024
Navigating the No Surprises Act & Price Transparency: Essential Insights for Compliance

Navigating the No Surprises Act & Price Transparency: Essential Insights for Compliance

Healthcare organizations face complex regulatory requirements under the No Surprises Act and Price Transparency rules. These policies mandate extensive fee disclosures across settings, and confusion is widespread—many hospitals remain unaware they must post every contracted rate. Non-compliance could lead to costly penalties, financial loss, and legal risks.  Join David M. Glaser Esq. as he shows you how to navigate these regulations effectively.

November 19, 2024
Post Operative Pain Blocks: Guidelines, Documentation, and Billing to Protect Your Facility

Post Operative Pain Blocks: Guidelines, Documentation, and Billing to Protect Your Facility

Protect your facility from unwanted audits! Join Becky Jacobsen, BSN, RN, MBS, CCS-P, CPC, CPEDC, CBCS, CEMC, and take a deep dive into both the CMS and AMA guidelines for reporting post operative pain blocks. You’ll learn how to determine if the nerve block is separately codable with real life examples for better understanding. Becky will also cover how to evaluate whether documentation supports medical necessity, offer recommendations for stronger documentation practices, and provide guidance on educating providers about documentation requirements. She’ll include a discussion of appropriate modifier and diagnosis coding assignment so that you can be confident that your billing of post operative pain blocks is fully supported and compliant.

October 24, 2024

Trending News

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24