Court Case Changing the Calculus for Providers Switching Patient Status

There are sure to be appeals or rule changes, so stay tuned.

The case I’m about to write about may ultimately become irrelevant, but it’s nonetheless quite noteworthy. Let me start with a brief history. Richard Bagnall was the original plaintiff, over a decade ago. He felt that he was unjustly denied Part A benefits. So, he did what anyone would, he sued the Secretary of U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).

The case bounced between the District Court and the Second Circuit a few times, with successive changes in named litigants. And finally, after a bench trial, the District Court handed down a decision. As expected, the Secretary appealed. In January, the Second Circuit affirmed the District Court’s decision.

The essential elements of the decision include the following:

  • Medicare beneficiaries who are initially admitted as inpatients, then changed to outpatients with observation services through the action of a hospital utilization review (UR) committee, hold a property interest in the inpatient Part A benefit.
  • The Secretary violated patients’ due process rights by failing to provide an appeal process.
  • Third, and most surprising, the District Court declared that the hospital’s UR committee’s actions when changing the patient’s status was a state action. This was because of, in the court’s words, “significant encouragement” from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS).
  • Finally, the District Court order gives appeal rights to essentially all beneficiaries since January 2009 who were admitted as inpatients and subsequently changed to outpatients with observation services.

It’s important to note that the decision only addresses deprivation of the rights of beneficiaries. It’s a complete unknown how the Secretary or a subsequent court will treat self-imposed losses by providers.

At this point, two things are certain. These are the following:

  • First, such patients have appeal rights. The decision did not provide a defined process, so beneficiaries will likely have to prosecute their cases though the court system. It’s not clear what remedies might be available for such plaintiffs. It’s also not clear to what extent the UR committees might share liability. This appeal process will likely be a significant burden on beneficiaries.
  • Second, the Secretary will either…
  • Do as ordered and promulgate rules to address the deprivation of beneficiaries’ due process rights; or 
    • Appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

As usual, I’d like to offer guidance for providers:

  • First: the ruling does not address impact on providers. Dr. Ronald Hirsch has previously raised a range of potential impacts, and the genuinely ironic twists of the UR committee qua government contractor.  
  • Second: It’s important to understand that the decision only addresses patients who received inpatient hospital services, but were improperly classified as outpatients. The Secretary could address the adverse financial impact of long observation stays, such as extensive co-pays, self-administered medications, and even patients without Part B coverage.
  • Third: I suspect that neither the courts nor the Secretary will add protections for providers that have improperly reclassified these patients.
  • Fourth: until the case is appealed, or the Secretary promulgates rules, providers should review UR processes to ensure that patients are not improperly reclassified as outpatients. There should be very clear reasons why the status of an inpatient hospitalized beyond two midnights is changed.
  • Finally, providers should consider steps to prevent physicians from entering observation orders on their own initiative.

Here are links to the relevant court filings in the case:

Alexander v Azar:

https://justiceinaging.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Memorandum-of-Decision-03-27-19.pdf

Barrows v Becerra:

https://justiceinaging.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/BarrowsvBecerra.pdf

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

John K. Hall, MD, JD, MBA, FCLM, FRCPC

John K. Hall, MD, JD, MBA, FCLM, FRCPC is a licensed physician in several jurisdictions and is admitted to the California bar. He is also the founder of The Aegis Firm, a healthcare consulting firm providing consultative and litigation support on a wide variety of criminal and civil matters related to healthcare. He lectures frequently on black-letter health law, mediation, medical staff relations, and medical ethics, as well as patient and physician rights. Dr. Hall hopes to help explain complex problems at the intersection of medicine and law and prepare providers to manage those problems.

Related Stories

When the Doctor is the Patient

When the Doctor is the Patient

First of all, it was NOT Mouse’s fault.  About a month ago, my geriatric, orange tabby cat slipped past me out the door and into

Read More

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Enhancing Outcomes with CDI-Coding-Quality Collaboration in Acute Care Hospitals

Enhancing Outcomes with CDI-Coding-Quality Collaboration in Acute Care Hospitals

Join Angela Comfort, DBA, MBA, RHIA, CDIP, CCS, CCS-P, as she presents effective strategies to strengthen collaboration between CDI, coding, and quality departments in acute care hospitals. Angela will also share guidance on implementing cross-departmental meetings, using shared KPIs, and engaging leadership to foster a culture of collaboration. Attendees will gain actionable tools to optimize documentation accuracy, elevate quality metrics, and drive a unified approach to healthcare goals, ultimately enhancing both patient outcomes and organizational performance.

November 21, 2024
Comprehensive Inpatient Clinical Documentation Integrity: From Foundations to Advanced Strategies

Comprehensive Outpatient Clinical Documentation Integrity: From Foundations to Advanced Strategies

Optimize your outpatient clinical documentation and gain comprehensive knowledge from foundational practices to advanced technologies, ensuring improved patient care and organizational and financial success. This webcast bundle provides a holistic approach to outpatient CDI, empowering you to implement best practices from the ground up and leverage advanced strategies for superior results. You will gain actionable insights to improve documentation quality, patient care, compliance, and financial outcomes.

September 5, 2024
Advanced Outpatient Clinical Documentation Integrity: Mastering Complex Narratives and Compliance

Advanced Outpatient Clinical Documentation Integrity: Mastering Complex Narratives and Compliance

Enhancing outpatient clinical documentation is crucial for maintaining accuracy, compliance, and proper reimbursement in today’s complex healthcare environment. This webcast, presented by industry expert Angela Comfort, DBA, RHIA, CDIP, CCS, CCS-P, will provide you with actionable strategies to tackle complex challenges in outpatient documentation. You’ll learn how to craft detailed clinical narratives, utilize advanced EHR features, and implement accurate risk adjustment and HCC coding. The session also covers essential regulatory updates to keep your documentation practices compliant. Join us to gain the tools you need to improve documentation quality, support better patient care, and ensure financial integrity.

September 12, 2024

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Patient Notifications and Rights: What You Need to Know

Patient Notifications and Rights: What You Need to Know

Dr. Ronald Hirsch provides critical details on the new Medicare Appeal Process for Status Changes for patients whose status changes during their hospital stay. He also delves into other scenarios of hospital patients receiving custodial care or medically unnecessary services where patient notifications may be needed along with the processes necessary to ensure compliance with state and federal guidance.

December 5, 2024
Navigating the No Surprises Act & Price Transparency: Essential Insights for Compliance

Navigating the No Surprises Act & Price Transparency: Essential Insights for Compliance

Healthcare organizations face complex regulatory requirements under the No Surprises Act and Price Transparency rules. These policies mandate extensive fee disclosures across settings, and confusion is widespread—many hospitals remain unaware they must post every contracted rate. Non-compliance could lead to costly penalties, financial loss, and legal risks.  Join David M. Glaser Esq. as he shows you how to navigate these regulations effectively.

November 19, 2024
Post Operative Pain Blocks: Guidelines, Documentation, and Billing to Protect Your Facility

Post Operative Pain Blocks: Guidelines, Documentation, and Billing to Protect Your Facility

Protect your facility from unwanted audits! Join Becky Jacobsen, BSN, RN, MBS, CCS-P, CPC, CPEDC, CBCS, CEMC, and take a deep dive into both the CMS and AMA guidelines for reporting post operative pain blocks. You’ll learn how to determine if the nerve block is separately codable with real life examples for better understanding. Becky will also cover how to evaluate whether documentation supports medical necessity, offer recommendations for stronger documentation practices, and provide guidance on educating providers about documentation requirements. She’ll include a discussion of appropriate modifier and diagnosis coding assignment so that you can be confident that your billing of post operative pain blocks is fully supported and compliant.

October 24, 2024
The OIG Update: Targets and Tools to Stay in Compliance

The OIG Update: Targets and Tools to Stay in Compliance

During this RACmonitor webcast Dr. Ronald Hirsch spotlights the areas of the OIG’s Work Plan and the findings of their most recent audits that impact utilization review, case management, and audit staff. He also provides his common-sense interpretation of the prevailing regulations related to those target issues. You’ll walk away better equipped with strategies to put in place immediately to reduce your risk of paybacks, increased scrutiny, and criminal penalties.

September 19, 2024

Trending News

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24